Matt Barrie is considered a genius founder behind Freelancer.com, which is one of the top five global online platforms for hiring freelancers. However, his way to the sky was neither direct nor easy. Before he could build his empire, Barrie confused himself with different ventures, learning by making expensive mistakes about the time, market, and at last he was able to create something that lasts.
The Early Years: Building a Foundation
Matt Barrie grew up in Australia and was always fascinated by how things worked. From the very beginning, technology and solving problems have looked very attractive to him. While other kids might have chosen to play sports, Barrie was taking apart electronic devices and trying to figure out the logic of the systems. Subsequently, he made up his mind to major in electrical engineering at the University of Sydney and graduate with honours.
However, it was not sufficient for Barrie to just acquire technical knowledge. He was equally sure that knowing business was as important as knowing technology. So, he got his MBA from Stanford University of the best business schools in the world. He thought that this mix of engineering skills with business knowledge would make him a kind of superpower. He was the first to see the way to success in entrepreneurship.
After getting his degrees and having the confidence, Barrie went back to Australia to start something big. He was technically skilled to make advanced products, and with his business education, he could develop companies around these products. What he still lacked was the street knowledge that only comes from getting it wrong. That lesson was coming, and it would cost him a lot more than any university degree.
The Network Security Company That Lost Spent Millions
After finishing his education, Barrie plunged into the deep end. He co-founded a hardware and network security company, convinced they were building something revolutionary. The technology they developed was truly impressive: systems capable of doing gigabit pattern-matching on network traffic-basically, a way to analyze huge amounts of data moving through networks at incredible speeds. This was cutting-edge stuff, quite beyond what more than a handful of companies worldwide could even attempt.
The reason was not the technology. The demand for the product did not exist. Barrie had created something for a market that wasn’t there. Companies were not ready to fork out money for this level of security. The internet was just its early stages, and most companies didn’t see online security threats as their main concern that needed to be addressed by spending millions of dollars. It was not the right time at all. Basically, his way of thinking was not recognised, as he had developed a solution for a problem that didn’t exist, and nobody would have expected that anyone would care about it at that time.
The company has been close to folding for a long time. The feeling of every day was that of pushing a boulder uphill. They managed to raise money from investors, around thirty million dollars over roughly six years. But raising money and making money are two very different things. The business was a constant battle, what Barrie calls a “hard slog.” Meetings with clients went nowhere. Sales cycles dragged on forever. The team worked endless hours trying to convince people they needed something they didn’t think they needed.
Barrie watched his investors’ money drain away on salaries, development costs, and marketing efforts that produced minimal returns. Eventually, Intel bought the company. On paper, this sounds like success. In reality, it was more like a mercy purchase. Barrie later called this experience his “thirty million dollar MBA.” That’s an expensive education.
BidItOut: The Clone That Never Took Off
After leaving the hardware world, Barrie decided to try something different. He noticed the rise of freelance marketplaces online and thought he spotted an opportunity. He was tired of building physical products that took forever to develop. Web businesses seemed faster, cheaper, and more scalable. Plus, he could see that outsourcing and remote work were becoming real trends, not just fads.
He launched a website called Bid-it-out.com. The idea was to copy GetAFreelancer’s model by building a marketplace where freelancers could be hired for projects. In a move that looked clever at the time, he employed freelancers to make the site itself. Why hire expensive developers to do the work when you could outsource it cheaply? It seemed like he was demonstrating the concept by using it: if freelancers could build a freelance marketplace, then definitely the model works.
However, while he was building BidItOut, he came to know of a very irritating fact. There were already numerous small companies on the internet that were doing the same thing as his. Everyone has copied GetAFreelancer. The market was packed full of almost identical platforms, each fighting for the same small pool of users. His clone was just another face in a very crowded room. There was absolutely nothing unique about BidItOut that would give users a reason to pick it instead of its competitors.
It seemed completely futile to start from scratch in such a market. It would take years and a lot of money just to create a brand, get users, and compete with the players that were already there. Barrie came to a conclusion which was unlike any other. He thought it would be better to just purchase an existing player rather than make one from the ground up.
The Messy Purchase of GetAFreelancer
Barrie acquired GetAFreelancer.com for a price close to two and a half million dollars. Pretty much, it looked like a good decision. If you can buy a company that is already generating revenue and has users, then why would you need to start from scratch? GetAFreelancer was among the recognised names in the freelance marketplace sector. It had visitors, active users, and brand recognition. Barrie felt he could take this foundation and build something truly great on top of it.
However, the reality of the purchase was quite different, and it was actually quite shocking. The place was a mess. It seemed like the design was made in a person’s basement in 1999. The user interface was confusing and ugly. Simple features were not functioning properly. Few web pages were loading slowly. The code was a tangled mess that made even simple changes complicated. But worst of all was the business model itself. GetAFreelancer had something called a “gold membership” that let users avoid paying commission on transactions, meaning the site was processing lots of activity but making almost no money from it.
Barrie had purchased a bustling marketplace that was making very little money. He made a lot of changes to the site and tried to figure out how to monetise the traffic for months, but to no avail. Each tiny improvement took far more time than was initially planned. Customers were unhappy with every alteration. The set of technologies used was a chaotic and old one.
This was an exhausting period. For the first time, Barrie was responsible for a company with real users and real problems. Unlike his hardware venture, where the market didn’t exist, this time the market existed, but the execution was terrible. He had to rebuild almost everything while keeping the site running and users happy. It felt like trying to repair a flying plane.
What Went Wrong: The Costly Lessons
In retrospect, all of Barrie’s failures boiled down to a couple of painful lessons. First, timing matters more than technology. His security company was loaded with brilliant engineers and solid products, but they were just too early. No amount of hard work can force a market to care before it’s ready. You can build the perfect solution, but if people don’t feel the pain of the problem yet, they won’t pay to solve it.
The competition is brutal. When BidItOut came online, jumping into a crowded space and not adding anything new was naive. Markets don’t reward clones unless you have massive advantages in execution, money, or distribution. Barrie had none of these. He was competing against established players with deeper pockets and larger user bases. Without a point of difference, BidItOut would end up like every other option out there-something else to choose from.
Thirdly, it is at times more difficult to buy a broken business than to simply start a new one. The platform GetAFreelancer was associated with users, but unfortunately, it also came with impolite and unwise decisions that were deeply integrated into its code and culture for the past several years. It is a very stressful situation, fixing someone’s mess while they watch and judge you. Barrie had to dig his way out of technical debt, change deeply ingrained behaviours of users, and regain the trust of a community that was doubtful of the new management.
The ghostly issues kept showing up like a house whose problems have been hidden, and each of them required time and money to fix. At times, the cheapest way to go is actually the costliest one.
The Rise of Freelancer.com
Despite the expensive failures over many years, Matt Barrie didn’t give up. He took the broken GetAFreelancer platform and, over time, turned it around. He resolved the monetisation issues by closing the loophole of gold membership and initiating an appropriate commission structure. He enhanced user experience through a complete design overhaul. He invested in better infrastructure for technology to make the site much faster and more reliable.
At the end of the day, he consolidated all his branding under a new title: Freelancer.com. However, this was not the only thing – it was not simply a cosmetic change; it was a total redefinition of the platform. Barrie leveraged every bit of the lesson he got from his previous failures to create something that really worked. He got it for the first time – market timing. He was aware of how to set the company apart from the competitors. He was tough on himself, but that was the way he learned how to develop a business model that was viable in the long run. He finally understood market timing and knew how to differentiate from the competition.
Today, Freelancer.com is a publicly listed company on the Australian Securities Exchange, and Barrie serves as CEO. The platform connects millions of employers with freelancers worldwide and generates real revenue. The company has facilitated billions of dollars in transactions and operates in hundreds of countries. The lessons of his thirty-million-dollar education weren’t wasted after all. Every failure had taught him something vital, which made Freelancer.com possible.
Lessons to Take Away from Barrie’s Journey
The first lesson to be learned from Barrie’s story is that market timing beats perfect execution. You might build the best product in the world, but if customers are not ready to buy it, you will struggle. Before you invest years and millions of dollars, at least validate that people actually feel the pain you’re solving and that they’re willing to pay for a solution right now, not someday in the future.
The second takeaway is that, absolutely, competition matters a lot more than the majority of entrepreneurs want to admit. It is almost impossible to step into a market full of rivals where you don’t have a clear edge. If you decide to take on a saturated market, then it is a must that you have something that is either remarkably different or significantly better. Matching the others in the market is not enough. Barrie discovered this through the experience of BidItOut, and he only managed to make it when he was able to gain scale and efficiency at a level higher than competitors.
The third lesson is that failure is very costly, but it is also priceless. Barrie has, in effect, thrown away 30 million dollars and quite a few years of his life to learn things that cannot be taught in a business school. It was only through those failures that he acquired the decision-making ability, toughness, and hands-on experience which he later used to succeed with Freelancer.com. Failure should not frighten you, but you must learn from it. Every mistake is costly, so make sure that you are extracting the greatest possible educational value from each of them.
To know more about Matt Barrie, visit his X, LinkedIn, his company website, and Freelancer.com’s Instagram and X.
Read about Matt Barrie’s eventual success story of Freelancer.com.
Want to read more stories of business failures that led to ultimate success? Check out Inspirepreneur Magazine.
