A federal judge on Tuesday dismissed a challenge by the largest US business lobby group against President Donald Trump’s $100,000 fee related to the allocation of new H-1B visas to highly skilled foreigners.
Judge Beryl Howell of the US District Court in Washington DC has dismissed the contention of the US Chamber of Commerce that it violates federal immigration laws as it will cause employers to reduce jobs as well as the services they offer.
Chamber Says Small Businesses Cannot Afford the Fee
Howell is an appointee of the Democratic former President Barack Obama. The White House had not yet commented upon this inquiry. The executive vice president and chief counsel for the Chamber, Daryl Joseffer, says many small and medium-sized businesses won’t be able to afford the cost.
The H1B Visa program facilitates American employers hiring individuals possessing skills in specialty fields. Tech companies are major consumers of such employees, who are holders of H1B visas. The program provides a total of 65,000 visas every year, along with 20,000 for individuals possessing an advanced level of education, valid for three to six years.
Fee Sharply Increases Cost of Hiring Foreign Workers
The fee associated with taking up an H-1B visa under Trump’s order would significantly rise, from the current range of $2,000 to $5,000. The Chamber, suing the matter, contends that with the new fee, those employers utilising the H-1B visa program would be given the option of either significantly raising their wage bill or cutting back their hiring of high-skilled workers.
A coalition of Democratic-led states within the US and employers and religious organisations has also filed suits challenging the fee. In the order compelling the payment of the fee, President Trump relied on the provision of federal immigration law to prevent the entry of aliens deemed harmful to the interests of the United States.
Howell on Tuesday stated that Trump had sufficiently supported his argument about the H-1B program having an overriding effect on American workers by citing instances of firms letting go of thousands of American employees at the same time as they applied for H-1B visas. This $100,000 fee obligation is a substantial jump from the preceding fees of $2,000 to $5,000. It can add millions of dollars in labour costs for companies employing more than one H-1B individual annually.
Technology firms have been leading users of H-1B visas, hiring software engineers and data scientists, among others. The proposed fee may make these companies change how they recruit employees. The argument presented by small and medium-sized companies is that they will be most affected by this cost increase. Although this might not be an issue for giant technology companies, the smaller companies argue that they simply cannot afford $100,000 per visa.
The Chamber of Commerce contends that this fee exceeds Trump’s power and is contrary to what Congress structured concerning the H-1B visa program. However, this is not how Judge Howell ruled in this case. According to Judge Howell, Trump has broad power over immigration law concerning the restriction of entry into the country of foreign nationals.
Other cases relating to the fee remain pending before federal courts. The states led by Democrats contend that the fee will negatively impact their economies because it will make it difficult for employers to fill vacant positions. Employers, non-profits, and religious institutions also sued, claiming that the fee would make it impossible for them to attract the workers they need to benefit communities.
Officials in the Trump administration have explained the fee as being necessary in order to protect American workers. There are too many corporations utilising the H-1B visa program to replace American workers with foreign workers.
The court held that Trump has given sufficient evidence of firms cutting back on American employees who apply for H1-B visas. This fulfils a condition that it is in the US interests to limit these visas.
Keep yourself updated with the recent travel and business news from around the world by visiting Inspirepreneur Magazine.
